Tue Sep 16, 2008 7:36 pm by astra
Dear Kim and Randy,
I was friends with your daughter when she was in the Sea Org. In fact, I was in charge of her when she was routing out.
Please listen to Melanie. Please put aside the role of a Scientologist for a moment and take on the role of a parent. What Melanie has told you is true. The abuse she suffered happened. I remember Melanie struggling so much to be a "good" sea org member. She tried her best at being a word clearer and course supervisor. She was even our "teacher" for a while when the sea org members who were minors sat in a room on Saturdays doing spelling bees to supposedly fulfill the requirement that we attend school. We all tried are best to conform, be good sea org member and work under abusive and deplorable conditions. It was too much for her, and later it was too much for me and I left. Many people have left with similar stories, too many to deny that something was very very wrong.
The abuse that I suffered, from regular sleep deprivation, constant verbal abuse and living in fear of being sent to the RPF, being deprived of an education and made to work well beyond the hours that were legal for a child to work were bad enough. But Melanie suffered even worse abuse. She didn't deserve the abuse and she doesn't deserve anyone denying what she went through.
I am a parent now myself and my daughter is my #1 priority. It is not too late to make your family your priority again too. I know that you feel that the work you are doing and being dedicated Scientologists is more important, that you have made the ultimate sacrifice. But please consider... what kind of religion makes you sacrifice your family? I don't think that Melanie expects you to give up your religion, only listen to her, acknowledge the abuse she suffered and please don't justify it. Speaking out about abuse suffered is not attacking a religion. Children who grew up in Catholic households who suffered abuse at the hands of certain priests were not attacking Catholisism. Children who grew up in the sea org and suffered abuse are similarly simply speaking out about what happened.
Taking steps to eliminate the abuse is the only solution. Denying it will not solve the problem, nor will it make the world a better place.
Please consider this. Please put your daughter first. Please don't let another family be destroyed by this destructive disconnection policy. Please don't miss out on the rest of your daughter's life, not to mention your grandchildren.
Please know that I write this message with a lump in my throat, so sad for Melanie, sad that Melanie and I are in the same position. My mom has not spoken to me in over 8 years. My daughter is missing out on having a grandma. Please don't let this happen. I love Melanie, she is truly a good and caring person. She deserves so much more and frankly so do you. It is not too late to prove that being a Scientologist does not mean disconnecting from your family, or putting up with abuse.
Astra Woodcraft